North Woods still qualify for
national park status
Letter to the editor
The letter ("Does North Woods meet criteria for
national park?," Sept. 28) asking whether
national park?," Sept. 28) asking whether
the national park proposed by Roxanne Quimby
has "natural characteristics" that qualify it
has "natural characteristics" that qualify it
for National Park System designation, raises fair
questions.
questions.
In 1937, a reconnaissance team sent by the
National Park Service director did an intensive
National Park Service director did an intensive
survey of the region around Katahdin. The team
recommended the designation of a
recommended the designation of a
327,978-acre national park that included not only
Katahdin, but also the lands proposed
Katahdin, but also the lands proposed
by Roxanne Quimby for national park designation.
In its report, the team wrote that it "unanimously agrees"
that the proposed national park
that the proposed national park
"is of national geologic and biologic importance and that
it possesses outstanding
it possesses outstanding
supplemental scenic and historic values, all of which taken
collectively, qualify the
collectively, qualify the
area for national park and monument system purposes."
The area proposed by Roxanne Quimby as a new national
park qualified three-quarters
park qualified three-quarters
of a century ago, and it still meets the criteria today. Of
course, the significance of
course, the significance of
the proposed national park land is enhanced by being
adjacent to Baxter State Park and Katahdin.
adjacent to Baxter State Park and Katahdin.
Indeed, the protection of this area would benefit Baxter
Park by buffering it from development
Park by buffering it from development
and including areas that were not originally included in
Baxter State Park.
Baxter State Park.
As for the question whether a new national park would
attract more visitors to the region,
attract more visitors to the region,
several studies project a significant increase in visitation,
because a national park would
because a national park would
greatly raise the public profile of the area and offer
high-quality education and recreation
high-quality education and recreation
programs. The national park brand is so well regarded
that it serves as a visitor magnet.
that it serves as a visitor magnet.
A new national park in the Katahdin region would be
an environmental, economic and
an environmental, economic and
recreational boon to the area and to all of Maine.
Lois Winter
Portland, Maine
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quimby adds more than 11,000 acres
to land holdings
Roxanne Quimby
Conservationist Roxanne Quimby has purchased another
11,000 acres east of Baxter State
Park, expanding her already-sizable land holdings in the
Katahdin region and potentially
adding another wrinkle to the debate over her national park plan.
Quimby’s nonprofit land conservation foundation, Elliotsville
Plantation Inc., announced
Wednesday that Quimby had bought 11,291 acres south of
Shin Pond in T4 R7 and T5 R7.
The land, which Quimby purchased from the timberland and
development company Lakeville
Shores Inc., includes substantial acreage on both sides of the
Seboeis River as well as Peaked
Mountain. A press release from Elliotsville Plantation Inc. said
the property is notable for its
white-water canoeing, wild brook trout fishery, upland forests
and wetlands.
A co-founder of the Burt’s Bees natural beauty products line,
Quimby has used her wealth to
purchase more than 100,000 acres of forestland in Maine.
The vast majority of Quimby’s land — including the most recent
purchase — is located in the
Katahdin region north of Millinocket and east of Baxter State
Park. And it’s in that region that
Quimby has made her boldest and most hotly debated move
yet: a proposal to donate 70,000
acres to the federal government for the creation of a new
North Woods National Park.
The Seboeis River tract is not part of the 70,000 acres Quimby
hopes will become Maine’s
second national park — a desire that is far from being fulfilled
given the opposition to federal
land ownership among some residents. But in the news release
announcing the acquisition,
Elliotsville Plantation Inc. suggested that the new land south of
Shin Pond could play a role as
Quimby seeks to build public support for her park plan.
The foundation said Quimby will allow hunting, snowmobiling
and other traditional uses
on the land for one year.“Long term, the acquisition will be part
of EPI’s larger plan for
multiple-use motorized recreation, hunting and sustainable
working forest east of the East Branch
[of the Penobscot River] to balance EPI’s proposed donation
of 70,000 acres west of
the East Branch for a national park,” the release stated.
Mark Leathers, a resource consultant at James W. Sewall Co.
who works with Quimby,
could not be reached for comment on Wednesday. However,
Quimby reportedly has
offered area snowmobile clubs five years of access to trails on
her property in exchange
for their support for a feasibility study of her national park
proposal.
The Bowlin-Matagammon-Shin Pond Snowmobile Club is
among
the groups weighing
Quimby’s offer. The club grooms several scenic trails
within Quimby’s new tract as well
as part of the ITS 114 snowmobile trail that extends into
the land, according to club secretary
Terry Hill, who also runs Shin Pond Village campground
and cottages.
Hill declined to comment on Quimby’s new land acquisition
before her club’s Oct. 20
meeting during which members will discuss whether to
support a park feasibility study
in return for five years of guaranteed access to trails on
Quimby land.
Bob Meyers, executive director of the Maine Snowmobile
Association, said the more
land Quimby owns in the region “the more of a wedge she
has” to put under local
snowmobile clubs.
“It has put them in a terrible situation,” Meyers said.
While there has been talk about a North Woods national park
for more than a decade,
Quimby’s latest proposal has changed the debate considerably
in a region where “Ban
Roxanne” bumper stickers once were commonplace.
Quimby has picked up support from business groups, local
governments and residents
for at least a feasibility study by proposing a 70,000-acre park,
a fraction of the size
of the 3.2 million-acre park originally put forward by the group
RESTORE: The North Woods.
Additionally, Quimby convinced some former naysayers that her
proposal is at least worth
considering through her offers to donate 30,000 acres to the state
for recreational land open
to hunting and snowmobiling as well as her promise to create a
$20 million endowment for
the national park. Only Congress, the White House or the U.S.
Department of the Interior
can request a park feasibility study, and then only Congress can
create a new park.
Others, however, remain staunchly opposed to the federal
government owning any land in a
region often described as Maine’s “timber basket.” So it was
not surprising that some did not
welcome the news that Quimby had purchased additional land
in the region.
Millinocket Town Manager Eugene Conlogue, a vocal opponent
of Quimby’s national park
plan, said the latest purchase is just “her expanding her reach
into this area.”
“That’s too bad. That’s a real blow,” he added. “Roxanne is
trying to impose her vision on
how woods should be on an area that is based on the forest
products industry. We do not
welcome her taking land out of that industry.”
Supporters of Quimby’s proposal, on the other hand, predict
that a new national park would
bring tourists and economic development to a region that is
losing population and has struggled
to keep open its two paper mills. They also praise Quimby
for her willingness, in recent years,
to reach compromises with snowmobile clubs and sportsmen’s
organizations on use of her land.
11,000 acres east of Baxter State
Park, expanding her already-sizable land holdings in the
Katahdin region and potentially
adding another wrinkle to the debate over her national park plan.
Quimby’s nonprofit land conservation foundation, Elliotsville
Plantation Inc., announced
Wednesday that Quimby had bought 11,291 acres south of
Shin Pond in T4 R7 and T5 R7.
The land, which Quimby purchased from the timberland and
development company Lakeville
Shores Inc., includes substantial acreage on both sides of the
Seboeis River as well as Peaked
Mountain. A press release from Elliotsville Plantation Inc. said
the property is notable for its
white-water canoeing, wild brook trout fishery, upland forests
and wetlands.
A co-founder of the Burt’s Bees natural beauty products line,
Quimby has used her wealth to
purchase more than 100,000 acres of forestland in Maine.
The vast majority of Quimby’s land — including the most recent
purchase — is located in the
Katahdin region north of Millinocket and east of Baxter State
Park. And it’s in that region that
Quimby has made her boldest and most hotly debated move
yet: a proposal to donate 70,000
acres to the federal government for the creation of a new
North Woods National Park.
The Seboeis River tract is not part of the 70,000 acres Quimby
hopes will become Maine’s
second national park — a desire that is far from being fulfilled
given the opposition to federal
land ownership among some residents. But in the news release
announcing the acquisition,
Elliotsville Plantation Inc. suggested that the new land south of
Shin Pond could play a role as
Quimby seeks to build public support for her park plan.
The foundation said Quimby will allow hunting, snowmobiling
and other traditional uses
on the land for one year.“Long term, the acquisition will be part
of EPI’s larger plan for
multiple-use motorized recreation, hunting and sustainable
working forest east of the East Branch
[of the Penobscot River] to balance EPI’s proposed donation
of 70,000 acres west of
the East Branch for a national park,” the release stated.
Mark Leathers, a resource consultant at James W. Sewall Co.
who works with Quimby,
could not be reached for comment on Wednesday. However,
Quimby reportedly has
offered area snowmobile clubs five years of access to trails on
her property in exchange
for their support for a feasibility study of her national park
proposal.
The Bowlin-Matagammon-Shin Pond Snowmobile Club is
among
the groups weighing
Quimby’s offer. The club grooms several scenic trails
within Quimby’s new tract as well
as part of the ITS 114 snowmobile trail that extends into
the land, according to club secretary
Terry Hill, who also runs Shin Pond Village campground
and cottages.
Hill declined to comment on Quimby’s new land acquisition
before her club’s Oct. 20
meeting during which members will discuss whether to
support a park feasibility study
in return for five years of guaranteed access to trails on
Quimby land.
Bob Meyers, executive director of the Maine Snowmobile
Association, said the more
land Quimby owns in the region “the more of a wedge she
has” to put under local
snowmobile clubs.
“It has put them in a terrible situation,” Meyers said.
While there has been talk about a North Woods national park
for more than a decade,
Quimby’s latest proposal has changed the debate considerably
in a region where “Ban
Roxanne” bumper stickers once were commonplace.
Quimby has picked up support from business groups, local
governments and residents
for at least a feasibility study by proposing a 70,000-acre park,
a fraction of the size
of the 3.2 million-acre park originally put forward by the group
RESTORE: The North Woods.
Additionally, Quimby convinced some former naysayers that her
proposal is at least worth
considering through her offers to donate 30,000 acres to the state
for recreational land open
to hunting and snowmobiling as well as her promise to create a
$20 million endowment for
the national park. Only Congress, the White House or the U.S.
Department of the Interior
can request a park feasibility study, and then only Congress can
create a new park.
Others, however, remain staunchly opposed to the federal
government owning any land in a
region often described as Maine’s “timber basket.” So it was
not surprising that some did not
welcome the news that Quimby had purchased additional land
in the region.
Millinocket Town Manager Eugene Conlogue, a vocal opponent
of Quimby’s national park
plan, said the latest purchase is just “her expanding her reach
into this area.”
“That’s too bad. That’s a real blow,” he added. “Roxanne is
trying to impose her vision on
how woods should be on an area that is based on the forest
products industry. We do not
welcome her taking land out of that industry.”
Supporters of Quimby’s proposal, on the other hand, predict
that a new national park would
bring tourists and economic development to a region that is
losing population and has struggled
to keep open its two paper mills. They also praise Quimby
for her willingness, in recent years,
to reach compromises with snowmobile clubs and sportsmen’s
organizations on use of her land.
No comments:
Post a Comment