America's Pest Problem: It's Time to Cull the Herd
After nearly wiping out many wildlife species 50 years ago, Americans are once again living close--sometimes uncomfortably so--to all kinds of feral creatures. Why wildlife in the U.S. needs stronger management
Faced with an outbreak of lyme disease and rising deer-related car accidents, the city council of Durham, N.C., authorized bow hunting inside city limits in November. Authorities in San Jose, Calif., in the heart of Silicon Valley, voted to allow hunting wild pigs within that city in October. Rock Island, Ill., one of the five Quad Cities on the Mississippi River, recently approved bow hunting in town, provided that it occurs in green spaces — golf courses, parks, cemeteries — or on private land.
Across the country, hunting is poised for a comeback, and not just because the folks on Duck Dynasty make it look like so much fun. We have too many wild animals — from swine to swans. Whether you're a Walmart employee in Florida wondering what to do with the alligator at your door, a New Yorker with a hawk nesting on your high-rise or an Ohio golfer scattering a flock of Canada geese, you now live, work and play in closer proximity to untamed fauna than any other generation of Americans in more than a century.
Too many deer, wild pigs, raccoons and beavers can be almost as bad for the animals as too few. This is why communities across the country find themselves forced to grapple with a conundrum. The same environmental sensitivity that brought Bambi back from the brink over the last century now makes it painfully controversial to do what experts say must be done: a bunch of these critters need to be killed.
Read more: America's Pest Problem: It's Time to Cull the Herd - TIME http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2158676,00.html#ixzz2mIBEE8QJ
Faced with an outbreak of lyme disease and rising deer-related car accidents, the city council of Durham, N.C., authorized bow hunting inside city limits in November. Authorities in San Jose, Calif., in the heart of Silicon Valley, voted to allow hunting wild pigs within that city in October. Rock Island, Ill., one of the five Quad Cities on the Mississippi River, recently approved bow hunting in town, provided that it occurs in green spaces — golf courses, parks, cemeteries — or on private land.
Across the country, hunting is poised for a comeback, and not just because the folks on Duck Dynasty make it look like so much fun. We have too many wild animals — from swine to swans. Whether you're a Walmart employee in Florida wondering what to do with the alligator at your door, a New Yorker with a hawk nesting on your high-rise or an Ohio golfer scattering a flock of Canada geese, you now live, work and play in closer proximity to untamed fauna than any other generation of Americans in more than a century.
Too many deer, wild pigs, raccoons and beavers can be almost as bad for the animals as too few. This is why communities across the country find themselves forced to grapple with a conundrum. The same environmental sensitivity that brought Bambi back from the brink over the last century now makes it painfully controversial to do what experts say must be done: a bunch of these critters need to be killed.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: "Meril, Rick"
Date: December 1, 2013, 12:59:27 PM EST
To: "'letters@time.com'" <letters@time.com
Subject: America'sPest Problem
Mr. Von Drehle
I work in Media and completely understand your need(desperate at this point with so many not reading TIME any longer) to utilize provacative headlines on your Front Cover to lure readers to buy copies of uour magazine.
Let me caution you however that your headline--AMERICA'S PEST PROBLEM is truly self serving and does a terrible injustice to both the animals your are writing about and the human animals who are digesting the skewed and terribly off-based commentary you have put forth.
If there is a "animal pest" in the USA, it is the swelling 320 million plus human animals,,,,,having degraded all but about 1 percent of the land surface of our Country----
True, that NJ and New England have regrown their forest cover after it being razed several times by our ancestors over the past 400+ years,,,,,,,not true that it harbors biological diversity-----we have splintered it throughout, making it inhospitable to a host of native creatures(wwolves/pumas/lynx/wolverine, etc),,,,,,,making it extremely hospitable to "exotics"(like feral pigs, starlings, etc, etc)
Deer are more plentiful because their natural predators(wolves and pumas) are not east of the mississippi(save100 of them in Florida)--the occasional wandering puma does not make a breeding population---You need females to be on the ground and we are not letting them go into northern florida, let alone NJ et al. The breeding population of Pumas in Nebraska and South Dakota is being gunned down by liberal hunting seasons so that it makes it nearly impossible for "prospectors" out of those regions to come east and breed.
Coyotes will kill some fawns as will Black Bears in the first weeks after their birth in the Spring, but neither of these Carnivores are the deer eaters that wolves and pumas are.
Let us put Wolves and Pumas back in our woodlands---that is the optimum way for us to have less deer,,,,, with the healthiest deer remaining alive because wolves and pumas are not seeking trophies(thus letting the largest and strongest deer remaining in the woods,,,,,,,Lyme disease will then begin to ease back and forest regeneration will increase with a larger array of native plants taking hold.
The human hunting of deer is never going to relieve the proliferation of the hoofed browsers and other prey species-----The bottom line is that younger folks are not interested in hunting--and not reading TIME either-- They are video game and i-pad(ded) up and would rather shoot deer with their gameboys rather than with muzzel-loaders.
We human are the pests in the environment,,,,,,creating inbalance through our naïve and "me, me, me" humans come first ways............Let us do a better job of coexisting with returning native animals and find it in ourselves to internalize the fact that more is better when it comes to keeping all of the creators beings on the planet with us.
Best
Rick Meril
Calabasas, California
Thank you for responding to Von Drehle's ludicrous treatise on wildlife management. Grizzlies are pushing black bears into our suburbs, wolves now have robust populations...nonsense!
ReplyDeleteI am very disappointed that Time magazine published such an uninformed and actually biased feature. To further exacerbate the setback to enlightened public opinion, they had to make it a cover article.
That article is so bad I wouldn't even know where to start to refute Von Drehle's assertions and I am sure his mind is pretty set.
There is little doubt that you are correct in your suggestion that he is trying to sell magazines with his outrageous headline but also his attitudes seems to reveal a connection to the pro hunting bunch .i.e. hunting as state of the art wildlife management
Thanks Dave............we just have to keep pushing back against this ignorance and bias
ReplyDelete