I am re-printing my Feb 21, 2016 Blog entry regarding the conflicting theories surrounding the species designation controversy regarding Gray Wolves and Eastern Wolves................Are they one and the same?................Are so-called Eastern Wolves an admix of Gray Wolf and western Coyote as Princeton University's Bridgette vonHoldt and her research team claim or are Gray Wolves, Eastern Wolves two individual species as Princeton University's Linda Rutledge's research team concludes?.......................Linda has long put forth the Canis three-species paradigm(the model that makes most sense to this Blogger) to explain the family tree of the Wolf and Coyote in the USA and Canada....................In her words--- "There are two prevailing evolutionary models for North American Canis: (i) a two-species model that identifies grey wolves (C. lupus) and (western) coyotes (Canis latrans) as distinct species that gave rise to various hybrids, including the Great Lakes-boreal wolf (also known as Great Lakes wolf ), the eastern coyote (also known as Coywolf/brush wolf/ tweed wolf ), the red wolf and the eastern wolf"..................... "(On the other hand), the three-species model identifies the grey wolf, western coyote and eastern wolf (C. lycaon) as distinct species, where Great Lakes-boreal wolves are the product of grey wolf eastern wolf hybridization, eastern coyotes are the result of eastern wolf western coyote hybridization, and red wolves are considered historically the same species as the eastern wolf, although their contemporary genetic signature has diverged owing to a bottleneck associated with captive breeding"..........vonHoldt has just published a new paper reinforcing her theory that both the Gray and Eastern Wolves are an admix of Gray Wolves and Western Coyotes........In her most recent paper on the subject, Rutledge counters by saying: "The recognition of the eastern wolf as a separate species does not exclude the possibility that a grey wolf eastern wolf hybrid animal (previously identified as Canis lupus lycaon, boreal/ Ontario-type, similar to a Great Lakes-boreal wolf currently located in the Great Lakes states and across Manitoba, northern Ontario, and northern Quebec, historically inhabited the northeastern United States alongside eastern wolves, and there is some evidence to support the historical presence of both Canis types"................ "The recognition of C. lycaon(eastern/red wolf) should not, therefore, influence grey wolf delisting decisions in the USA., in light of the current funding gap for biodiversity"...............Anotherwards, both the Great Lakes Gray/Eastern Wolf admix and the Eastern/Red Wolf species should be afforded Endangered Species protection east of the Mississippi and a full rewilding of both animals should be pursued in all the habitat previously identified by biologists as suitable for long term persistence of the wolves-low human and roadway densities, continuous/contiguous forest regions and whitetail deer habitat of at pre colonial or higher 6 to 12 deer per square mile..................Both Linda's and Bridgette's full papers can be read by clicking on the links below.............Excellent research and fascinating and relatively easy to read verbage for the layman to digest and ingest .....Enjoy this one!

http://rsbl.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/11/7/20150303.full-text.pdf


Evolutionary biology RAD sequencing and genomic simulations resolve hybrid origins within North American Canis

 L. Y. Rutledge1 , S. Devillard2 , J. Q. Boone3 , P. A. Hohenlohe4 and B. N. White1 1 Biology Department, Trent University, 2140 East Bank Drive, Peterborough, Ontario, K9J 7B8 Canada 2 Universite´ de Lyon, F-69000, Lyon; Universite´ Lyon 1; CNRS, UMR5558, Laboratoire de Biome´trie et Biologie Evolutive, F-69622, Villeurbanne, France 3 Floragenex Inc., Eugene, OR 97405, USA 4 Department of Biological Sciences, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID 83844, USA 

Top predators are disappearing worldwide, significantly changing ecosystems that depend on top-down regulation. Conflict with humans remains the primary roadblock for large carnivore conservation, but for the eastern wolf (Canis lycaon), disagreement over its evolutionary origins presents a significant barrier to conservation in Canada and has impeded protection for grey wolves (Canis lupus) in the USA.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

WHOLE GENOME SEQUENCE ANALYSIS SHOWS THAT
TWO ENDEMIC SPECIES OF NORTH AMERICAN WOLF 
ARE ADMIXTURES OF THE COYOTE AND GRAY WOLF


Bridgette vonholdt, James Cahill, Zhenxin Fan, Llan Gronau,
Jacqueline Robinson, John Pollinger, Beth Shapiro, Jeff Wall, Robert Wayne

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BxT5tRF1ZBFnbklDcUZrSk5xSnc/view?pref=2&pli=1

Gray Wolf(found West and north of the
 Great Lakes)

Great Lakes Wolf(admix of Gray and
Eastern Wolf)

Here, we use 127 235 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) identified from restriction-site associated DNA sequencing (RAD-seq) of wolves and coyotes, in combination with genomic simulations, to test hypotheses of hybrid origins of Canis types in eastern North America. 

Eastern Wolf(same as Red Wolf)
(found in the Eastern USA and
Canada)

Red Wolf(same as eastern wolf)(only 50
in the wild,in North Carolina Barrier
 Islands) 

A principal components analysis revealed no evidence to support eastern wolves, or any other Canis type, as the product of grey wolf  western coyote hybridization. In contrast, simulations that included eastern wolves as a distinct taxon clarified the hybrid origins of Great Lakes boreal wolves and eastern coyotes.


Western Coyote(historically found west of 
the Mississippi)

Eastern Coyote(western coyote/eastern
 wolf admix)

 Our results support the eastern wolf as a distinct genomic cluster in North America and help resolve hybrid origins of Great Lakes wolves and eastern coyotes. The data provide timely information that will shed new light on the debate over wolf conservation in eastern North America.