historical accounts of keystone predators and prey that occupied what we now call the State of Oklahoma

Pre Blog, some of the emails sent to you that generated strong positive response centered around historical accounts of what carnivores occupied the Americas circa 1500................................Oklahoma first hand accounts below:

Historical Accounts of Several Large Mammals in Oklahoma

Jack D. Tyler and Wendy J. Anderson

Department of Biological Sciences, Cameron University, Lawton, OK 73505

Pre-1900 accounts of the gray wolf, black bear, mountain lion, elk, and pronghorn in Oklahoma are reviewed. Because

Oklahoma was not opened to white settlement until late in the nineteenth century, early reports on the natural history of the

state are sparse, scattered, and frequently anecdotal.

INTRODUCTION

Because Indian Territory (present-day Oklahoma) was settled by Caucasians relatively later than

surrounding states (beginning in 1889), there is a paucity of information on the fauna of Oklahoma. Prior to the

twentieth century, the gray wolf

(Canis lupus), black bear (Ursus americanus), mountain lion (Felis concolor),

elk

(Cervus canadensis), and pronghorn (Antilocapra americana) were at least locally common in the area.

Since 1900, however, drastic reductions in their ranges and numbers have occurred. This paper reviews

historical references to these species (Table 1) and discusses reasons for their disappearance.

GRAY WOLF

One of the earliest wolf sightings in Oklahoma was by the French explorer Brevel. Brevel mentioned seeing

wolves in the Wichitas on his 1765 trip to Santa Fe (1). The Wichita Mountains are in Comanche County

(southwestern Oklahoma).

In 1718, de la Harpe (10), while traveling through Muskogee County near the present town of Haskell,

wrote: "One buffalo herd was followed by a pack of wolves as large as those in France." This is significant

because the observer noted the size of the wolves. Coyotes

(Canis latrans) are much smaller.

Wolf packs frequently accompanied herds of bison and elk. In 1820, Long (2), traveling along the Canadian

River in central Oklahoma, stated: "The bison and wolves moved slowly off to the right and left leaving a lane

for the party to pass . . ." And on the Chisholm Trail between the Cimarron River and the Salt Fork of the

Arkansas River, Borroum (3) wrote in 1871: "Buffalo, horses, elk, deer, antelope, wolves . . . were all mixed

together and it took several hours for them to pass . . . so that we could proceed . . ."

Seven times in

The Rambler in Oklahoma, Latrobe (4) referred to wolves. He noted their interaction with

bison in the prairie habitat: "The wolves hunt the straggling cows and calves in packs."

de Pourtales (5), on tour with Washington Irving, recounted: "I was awakened once or twice by a concert of

wolves, who howled in the thicket about twenty paces from me approach . . . We get a great deal of exercise by

riding twelve leagues a day and by chasing down wolves all around us . . . The prairies are full of them . . ."

Their camp was near the Canadian River south of Fort Gibson, probably in what is now Muskogee County.

Gould (6) asserted that the gray wolf was still present in Oklahoma as late as 1900. According to McCarley

(7), full-blooded red wolves (

C. rufus) were completely extirpated from the state by 1950.

BLACK BEAR

Bears were abundant in the oak cross timbers of central Oklahoma in the 1830s. Latrobe (4), who

accompanied Washington Irving, referred to bears five times in reporting his exploration of this region, and

stated that they were fat from feeding on a harvest of acorns. Gregg (8) made a similar observation: "Among the

cross timbers, the black bear is very common, living chiefly upon acorns and other fruits."

Bears were apparently plentiful across the area (6). Maley (9), while exploring the Red River (probably in

present-day Choctaw or Bryan County), observed many bears. de la Harpe (10), in what is now Pushmataha

County, killed a bear during a hunt for food in 1719. In 1823, a ranger with General E. P. Gaines (11) saw a bear

along the Grand River in northeast Oklahoma.

52 J.D. TYLER and W.J. ANDERSON

Proc. Okla. Acad. Sci. 70:51-55 (1990)

53 LARGE MAMMALS in OKLAHOMA

Proc. Okla. Acad. Sci. 70:51-55 (1990)

Ursus americanus

inhabited such diverse habitats as prairies, mountains and woodlands. Nuttall (12), an

early botanist, also took notes on the fauna of eastern Oklahoma. Nuttall said: ". . . in the morning our party fell

upon a favorite amusement, in the pursuit of two bears; harmlessly feeding in the prairies, which being fat were

soon overtaken and killed" (sic.).

In the Wichita Mountains of southwest Oklahoma, bears were once fairly common. Brevel mentioned bears

in the Wichitas (1). Keim (1) found fresh bear signs in 1869 on a tree near Mount Scott. Skins of a sow and cub

collected on Mount Scott by Gaut (30) are in the U.S. National Museum. According to Halloran and Glass (25),

the last four bears in the Wichitas were killed in 1934.

MOUNTAIN LION

Although the bobcat

(Felis rufus) is still widespread in Oklahoma, its larger relative, the mountain lion, was

probably extirpated by the early 1900's. This large cat impressed early travellers who encountered it.

The French explorer Brevel (1) in the Wichita Mountains in 1765 wrote: ". . . on the mountains, spotted

tiger (an early record of jaguar in Oklahoma?), panther, and wild cat." "Wild cat" refers to the bobcat; however,

the "spotted tiger" could possibly have been a jaguar. Jaguars ventured into southern Texas during this time

(14), but have never been recorded in Oklahoma. It is possible that Brevel saw the spotted cub of a mountain

lion.

On July 15, 1852, Bushman was hunting deer along the south branch of Cache Creek in southwestern

Oklahoma when he attempted to bring a fawn closer by "bleating." But, to his great surprise, he attracted instead

a mountain lion. Marcy (15) wrote of the incident: ". . . when immediately behind the fawn came a huge panther

bounding rapidly towards him." Marcy also encountered a cougar. While passing through present-day Tillman

County near Grandfield on May 17, 1852, he saw a large animal coming toward him. He wrote: "I fired several

shots which took effect . . . He was a fine specimen of the North American Cougar

(Felis concolor)" (15).

Records (16) mentioned mountain lions among many other mammals seen in 1800 near the Alfalfa-Major

County line. Payne (17) wrote that in February 1883, panthers, wild cats, prairie dogs, and jack rabbits, etc.,

were found along the Canadian River in McClain County, central Oklahoma. Sitgreaves and Woodruff (18),

during their travels through Oklahoma in 1858, stated: ". . . of quadrupeds (we) found but a few Dusky Wolves

(

Canis nubulis), panther (Felis buco) . . ." These scientific names have of course since been changed.

Woodhouse (19), an avid ornithologist, made camp at Childers Ford on the Verdigris River while passing

through Oklahoma during 1849. A quote from his journal reads: "I was awakened one night whilst in the camp

by the cry of a panther

(Felis concolor, Mountain Lion) . . . in the swamp in back of our tent." This would have

been in southwestern Rogers or northeastern Wagoner County.

The exact date that cougars were extirpated from Oklahoma is not known. Ranger Earl Drummond stated

that "the last cougar killed in the [Wichita] mountains was in 1900" (1).

ELK

In 1601, de Onate (2), traveling through what is now Roger Mills County in westcentral Oklahoma,

encountered ". . . deer which are as large as horses. They traveled in droves of two and three hundred and their

deformity (antlers?) causes one to wonder whether they are deer or some other animal." These were almost

certainly elk.

While de Onate did not specifically identify the animals he saw as elk, most explorers described them in

greater detail. Bean (20) crossed Oklahoma in 1832 with Washington Irving. Irving wrote of Bean: "He

abandoned his pursuit of the deer, and followed the newly discovered track. After some time he came in sight of

elk, and had several fair chances of shot, but was anxious to bring down a large buck, which kept in advance."

Elk travelled in large herds. Sibley (21) stated: "Numerous herds of elk and antelope were frisking in the

gay flower plain, giving life and animation to the charming scene." This was in 1811, probably in present-day

Alfalfa County. Long (22), while passing through western Oklahoma along the Canadian River, observed: "In

the afternoon the country we passed was swarming with innumerable herds of bison, wild horses, deer, elk, etc. .

. ." In northeastern Oklahoma in 1806,

54 J.D. TYLER and W.J. ANDERSON

Proc. Okla. Acad. Sci. 70:51-55 (1990)

Wilkinson (2) wrote: "It appeared as if we had just gotten into the region of game; for the herds of buffalo, elk,

goat (pronghorn), and deer surpassed credibility." The exact date that native elk disappeared from Oklahoma is

uncertain.

PRONGHORN

The pronghorn is strictly a mammal of open grasslands. Vast Oklahoma prairies once provided excellent

habitat for this animal, which probably surpassed even the bison in numbers.

The pronghorn can achieve speeds of up to 40 mph and the early explorers took note of this. While in the

Wichita Mountains in 1852, Marcy (15) spotted several pronghorns and remarked that several greyhounds in his

party could not catch them (1). Gregg (8) observed them near Richmond in Woodward County. He wrote:

"Although we had encountered but very few buffalo since we left Spring Valley, they now begin to make their

appearance again, though not in very large droves; together with the deer and the fleet antelope, which the latter

struck me as being much more tame in this wild section of the prairies than I had seen it elsewhere." Latrobe (4)

on October 30, 1832, entered the following passage in his journal: "A small group of goats or antelopes was

pointed out to me, but I was unable to approach them to give their figure or appearance with any distinctness."

It is conjectural as to when the last pronghorn left the grasslands of Oklahoma. Gaut (30) stated: "As late as

1890 antelope were numerous in Greer County southwest of Mount Scott . . ." Gould (6) wrote: ". . . in 1900

there were several droves of antelope in what is now Tillman County."

SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION

Historical references demonstrate that these five large mammals were a conspicuous element of Oklahoma's

fauna prior to the twentieth century. Why did they disappear? The major reason was the rapid expansion in

human population after the state was opened to settlement in 1889. As homesteaders settled into the territory,

widespread deforestation, burning, and plowing of the rich prairie sod followed. Overgrazing was commonplace

after barbed wire fences were erected. Because no game laws were in existence to protect wildlife, overhunting

was also rampant. In 1912, Barde (23) portrayed the opening of the state ". . . as though the lightnings of heaven

had fallen upon its wild life. Fires swept the country in all directions; armies of horsemen penetrated to remote

places; wagons rumbled over the hills and down the valleys; there was a tumult of shouting and the roar of guns,

and violence reigned, where until that day had been the peace of a primeval solitude. The slaughter had begun."

As ranchers moved in, they looked for possible solutions to the predator problem. Bounties were placed. In

1859, Mead (24) wrote: "Hunters with strychnia finally exterminated the wolves, myself and men killing some

5000 of them. They never molested people." Cougars were shot, wolves poisoned, and bears hunted down. All

animals that were thought to harm livestock were killed with great fervor.

Elk and pronghorn diminished quickly after white men entered Indian Territory because of extensive

hunting for food and sport.

Elk have been reintroduced into the Wichita Mountains Wildlife Refuge and parts of eastern Oklahoma,

and small numbers of pronghorns still roam the Panhandle. But the wolves, bears and cougars are gone.

Occasionally, a bear or mountain lion wanders into the state, but none of these large mammals is an important

component of Oklahoma's fauna today.